The Keeper of the Thresholds
An original take from the Under-Secretary to the Prime Minister’s Office – the most underrated role in the Italian government
In March 2026, the tension between Defence Minister Guido Crosetto and the Under-Secretary to the Prime Minister, Alfredo Mantovano, escalated into a political row, to the extent that the minister was forced to declare in the Senate his full confidence in his colleague.
The clash centred on military intelligence, and there was one institutional factor that made it possible: Mantovano, as well as being Secretary to the Council of Ministers, is the Delegated Authority for the Security of the Republic and holds responsibility for anti-drugs policy. The head of one of the country’s most important ministries thus found himself at loggerheads with an undersecretary – that is, a figure who occupies a lower rung in the formal government hierarchy.
This episode highlights a phenomenon that, in Italy, has been studied primarily through the lens of public law. The Under-Secretary to the Prime Minister is described in terms of the powers delegated to him, and his influence is attributed to the personal trust placed in him by the head of government. This article offers an original interpretation of an often underestimated role: the Undersecretary’s power stems from his control over the hurdles that every decision must clear in order to become a government act, and grows in proportion to the number of such hurdles he oversees.
A rule consisting of just a few lines
The legal basis is minimal. Law No. 400 of 1988 stipulates that the Under-Secretary designated in the decree of appointment is the Secretary of the Council of Ministers, performs the duties of that office, and is responsible for taking the minutes and maintaining the register of resolutions. In practice, the Undersecretary is also delegated the power to sign acts falling within the President’s remit which do not require a collective decision. The Council’s rules of procedure also entrust the Undersecretary with the coordination of the preparatory meeting – the so-called ‘pre-Council’ – and stipulate that the list of measures to be included on the agenda must be submitted to the President via the Undersecretary.
A comparison with the other undersecretaries speaks for itself. Legal doctrine refers tothe objectively marginal nature of the duties of undersecretaries within ministries, who work on sector-specific responsibilities delegated by the minister. The Under-Secretary to the Presidency, on the other hand, occupies the position where the work of all ministries converges, and does so on behalf of the President – that is, the body to which Article 95 of the Constitution entrusts the maintenance of political and administrative unity.
Four thresholds
Every government measure goes through at least four stages, and the Under-Secretary can oversee them all.
The first hurdle isthe agenda. Anything that does not make it onto the agenda is not decided upon, and Peter Bachrach and Morton Baratz demonstrated as early as the 1960s that the most effective form of power often lies in preventing an issue from even reaching the table. The pre-council is the institutional forum for this power. The controversy that accompanied Under-Secretary Boschi’s request in 2017 to examine ministerial documents in advance revealed, for once, the contours of this power.
The second threshold is the minutes. John Austin taught that certain utterances bring about the fact they name, and the deliberations of a collegial body belong to this category: they exist legally in the form in which they are recorded. The person in charge of the register safeguards the boundary between what the Council has discussed and what it has decided.
The third hurdle is communication. There is a further filter between the decision and the public account that is given of it, and the Under-Secretary, who sits at the table and is aware of the compromises reached, is in the best position to shape it.
The fourth threshold concerns what I refer to in my work as ‘communicative accountability’, that is, the extent to which a public decision can be traced back to an individual who remains accountable for it over time. On sensitive issues, such as intelligence, the Under-Secretary can absorb some of the scrutiny and allow the Prime Minister to maintain a distance. From this perspective, the figure of the ‘shadow man’ fulfils a specific function within the government’s structure.
The influence of an Under-Secretary therefore depends on the number of areas under their remit, rather than on the list of their responsibilities, and the history of the post confirms this.
From Andreotti to Letta
The first Secretary of the Council of the Italian Republic was Paolo Cappa, but it was Giulio Andreotti – appointed by De Gasperi on 31 May 1947 at the age of twenty-eight – who shaped the role. Andreotti held the post until January 1954 and expanded its remit to include, amongst other things, responsibility for the film industry, through which he contributed to the post-war revival of the Italian film industry – one of the main instruments in shaping the collective imagination of the time.
An anonymous chief of staff was able to write that, since then, the Under-Secretary has been the government’s ‘primary driving force’.
Under Giuliano Amato, from 1983 to 1987, the post came face to face with Craxi’s decisive leadership, and the role was described as the ‘government’s first-aid service’. Gianni Letta is said to have recalled that, at that time, the Under-Secretary, who kept the minutes, was not permitted to speak in the Council. The power to block decisions already existed, and was exercised quietly.
Letta took the model to its zenith. He was the first non-parliamentary Under-Secretary, appointed in 1994, and returned to Palazzo Chigi from 2001 to 2006 and from 2008 to 2011. In 2008, the intelligence law was amended to allow him to also assume the role of delegated authority, and control over the four thresholds was concentrated in a single person, who had no electoral mandate and was virtually absent from public debate.
Two ways of being an Under-Secretary
The role does not always carry the same weight. A recent study distinguishes between tandems in which the Under-Secretary is the President’s political and institutional right-hand man – such as Berlusconi-Letta, Draghi–Garofoli and Meloni–Mantovano, from those of a different nature, such as Gentiloni–Boschi and Conte–Giorgetti, and links the rise of this role to the government’s shift towards a monocratic model.
An analysis of the thresholds clarifies this link. In the first Conte government, Undersecretary Giancarlo Giorgetti belonged to the Lega, whilst the President had been nominated by the Five Star Movement and oversaw the thresholds on behalf of a coalition partner. The power was the same, but a different approach was required. The allocation of these responsibilities is also a decision made by the Prime Minister. Draghi entrusted intelligence matters to a dedicated Under-Secretary, Franco Gabrielli, separating them from the Council Secretariat, whilst Conte and Gentiloni did not appoint a delegated authority.
The concentration of thresholds
The Meloni government has opted for centralisation. To enable Mantovano to hold both the post of Secretary to the Council and responsibility for the intelligence services, the 2007 Intelligence Act has been amended once again, as had previously been the case for Letta. The agenda, minutes and accountability for the most sensitive dossiers thus converge in a single figure, who, in March 2023, whilst addressing the management of migrants – a matter falling within the remit of the Ministry of the Interior – drew a clear line with a blunt statement: ‘On this subject, I am the one who speaks’. The tension with Crosetto is the predictable consequence of this structure, because a minister heads a ministry, whilst the Under-Secretary oversees the processes through which all ministries operate.
Who monitors the thresholds?
The trend amongst European governments towards an increasingly centralised leadership – a phenomenon that Thomas Poguntke and Paul Webb have termed ‘presidentialisation’ – means that the role of the Prime Minister is set to grow in importance, and in Italy the debate on strengthening the Prime Minister’s powers is moving in the same direction. The more a government concentrates power at the top, the greater the influence of those who manage its internal workings.
The crux of the matter concerns accountability, because those who set the thresholds are held less accountable than those who cross them. Ministers appear before Parliament, sign legislation and face individual motions of no confidence, whilst the Under-Secretary to the Prime Minister exercises decisive power whilst being subject to minimal scrutiny. Recognising the nature of this power is essential to determining what checks and balances should accompany it, in a system that continues to measure the importance of offices by their formal rank.








