The democratic shield against foreign interference is not a black box to be opened only after a disaster has occurred

Carmelo Palma
19/11/2026
Frontiers

It is encouraging that the Senate has finally begun debating the ‘democratic shield’ billtabled by Senators Marco Lombardo and Carlo Calenda of Azione. However, for this promise to be fulfilled, there must be agreement on the institutional nature of this instrument and its political purpose. Optimism is warranted; enthusiasm, however, is less so at present.

The crux of the proposal is not to enshrine in law the fact that hybrid warfare exists. It is to develop tools to counter its effects. Hybrid warfare is not merely digitalised propaganda: it combines economic and personal corruption, covert funding, political infiltration, algorithmic manipulation, fake news, and coordinated campaigns designed to alter perceptions of reality and, with them, the free formation of consensus.

The case of Moldova should have cleared up any misunderstanding. In 2024, the Moldovan authorities exposed a vote-buying network linked to the pro-Russian oligarch Ilan Șor during the referendum to launch the process of accession to the European Union: over 130,000 citizens were involved (out of a population of just under three million) and around 15 million dollars were transferred in a single month via a Russian bank. 

Opinions are free, but buying and manufacturing consensus are not

It was not a question of persuading voters with a different opinion, but of buying votes and fabricating and spreading consensus through unlawful means and hostile manoeuvres. The ‘yes’ vote for Europe won by the narrowest of margins: 50.35 per cent to 49.65 per cent, a difference of just 10,564 votes, thanks to the support of Moldovans abroad, who voted overwhelmingly in favour of EU accession. Had only residents voted, Russia would have won. Cognitive warfare and material corruption are two sides of the same ‘special operation’, essentially similar in its aims – though not in its methods – to the one currently underway in Ukraine.

Two distinct but complementary levels of response are required. It is the responsibility of the security services to identify hostile networks and counter clandestine operations. But democracy cannot entrust its defence solely to the intelligence services. Public action is also required – action capable of exposing deceptive campaigns, revealing their funders and mechanisms, challenging manipulation and, where the legal conditions are met, ordering the reporting and removal of content intended to alter the ‘operating system’ of the democratic process.

Exposure is itself a means of defence. Making public the direction, funding and tactics behind manipulation restores citizens’ freedom to recognise it. Lombardo and Calenda’s proposal provides for independent supervisory bodies within the most significant news and media platforms, comprising experts selected by AGCOM, verifiable measures and reports to Parliament. Reducing the whole issue to a confidential matter of national security would mean making the fight against such practices more opaque and more open to suspicion of political bias. We need well-reasoned decisions, public oversight and, of course, guarantees of judicial redress for those who consider themselves victims of an abuse of power or unlawful discrimination.

Then there is the issue that many prefer not to address: the major digital platforms. Social media are not a neutral forum for public debate, but rather the propaganda and organisational infrastructure through which hostile campaigns are designed and amplified on an industrial scale. That power is concentrated in the hands of oligarchs and global groups whose economic and political interests are openly hostile to European autonomy and the traditional Euro-Atlantic balance. Imagining a shield that does not interfere with them is like designing an alarm system whilst leaving the keys with the thief.

Because criminal law alone is of little use

Criminal law alone serves little, if any, purpose, although it must, of course, be used to prosecute those who bribe, provide illegal funding, blackmail or commit other offences: these are matters of individual responsibility, to be established with all due safeguards. However, a phenomenon of such epoch-making significance as hybrid warfare – which represents the main threat to the stability of European democracies – cannot be dealt with in a court of law. Moreover, it would be utterly absurd to rely solely on court proceedings, which can last for months or years, as the sole response to a campaign of manipulation that has an immediate objective. Administrative measures are crucial: monitoring, reporting, making such operations identifiable, enforcing transparency, and taking action against unlawful practices and content through proportionate, verifiable and challengeable procedures that are also timely. 

If tens of thousands of anonymous accounts are activated within a matter of hours on a social media platform to support a party or a candidate, the first and foremost defence is to raise awareness of the situation and enable users to assess its effects. Defending freedom of expression means protecting dissent, not guaranteeing impunity for organised schemes designed to distort democratic debate and pretend that bot farms are the digital equivalent of Hyde Park’s Speakers’ Corner.

It is the same contradiction that emerges – even if few realise it – in the law against anti-Semitism passed by the Chamber of Deputies. It is right to define it, recognise it and condemn it; but if, as has been done, we fail to tackle the industrial-scale production and epidemic spread of anti-Jewish stereotypes – precisely where the platforms make them go viral, amplify them and profit from them – the solemnity of these definitions risks becoming nothing more than an alibi. It is not enough to proclaim what the evil is if we then stop at the threshold of the factory that produces it and the shops that peddle it.

In short, the democratic shield cannot be a black box that determines, after the event, the causes of the democratic system’s collapse. It must be the air escort that prevents democracy from being shot down by the surface-to-air missiles of hybrid warfare.